簡介:中國崛起引發擔憂,特別在東南亞。以中國和緬甸關係為例,本研究探討中國的實際政治影響力。儘管緬甸高度依賴中國,但其合作性有限,可能誇大中國影響。經濟影響力綜合指數顯示緬甸最依賴中國,但考慮政治改革和當地社區反對,中國的實際影響受限。
研究論文標題
China’s Economic Offensive and Its Discontent in Southeast Asia: Diminishing Footprints in Myanmar
中國的經濟攻勢及其在東南亞的不滿:緬甸的减弱足跡
作者
Ian Tsung-yen Chen(陳宗巖)
關鍵字
China, Myanmar, economic statecraft, Southeast Asia
中國、緬甸、經濟國策、東南亞
文章語言
英文
出版書籍
China’s Footprints in Southeast Asia
編者
- Maria Serena I. Diokno (Professor of History at the University of the Philippines Diliman)
- Hsin-Huang Michael Hsiao (Distinguished research fellow, Institute of Sociology, Academia Sinica, Taiwan)
- Alan H. Yang (Associate professor and associate research fellow, Graduate Institute of East Asian Studies and Institute of International Relations, National Chengchi University, Taiwan.)
主版社
National University of Singapore Press(國立新加坡大學出版社)
書籍連結
https://nuspress.nus.edu.sg/products/chinas-footprints-in-southeast-asia
引用
Chen, Ian Tsung-yen. 2019. “China’s economic offensive and its discontent in Southeast Asia: A crucial case study of Sino-Myanmar relations.” In China’s Footprints in Southeast Asia, edited by Maria Serena I. Diokno and Hsin-Huang Michael Hsiao (Singapore: National University of Singapore Press), pp. 63-89.

英文摘要
Although the rise of an economically powerful China benefits many developing countries, many worry about China’s surging regional and global influences, especially in Southeast Asia. It is true that China has risen fast, but how successfully it has translated its rising power into actual political influence remains a question. In this study I answer this question by examining a crucial case of the Sino-Myanmar relationship. Because Myanmar relies heavily on China, it is one of the most likely countries to be heavily influenced by China. If, however, Myanmar has been less cooperative under such an imbalanced relationship, then China’s actual influence may be exaggerated. I use the Composite Index of Economic Influence (CIEI) to show which country Myanmar depends on the most in terms of economic interdependence. The CIEI indicates that Myanmar relies on China the most and cannot be easily replaced in the short term. Given such a high interdependent relationship, however, evidence shows that since Myanmar started political reform in 2011, its behavior has begun to deviate from China’s positions on the issues of human rights and a nuclear-free world. Furthermore China’s influence has not been well received by the local communities who view Chinese-supported projects as exploitative economic adventurism. This study explores the causes of this opposition in an analysis of China’s investments in the Myitsone Dam and Letpadaung copper mine projects. Results suggest that China’s soft footprints do not appear as strong and welcome as perceived. The power from interdependent relationship requires political and social cohesion to take hold.
中文摘要
雖然經濟實力強大的中國崛起對許多發展中國家有益,但許多人擔心中國在區域和全球層面的影響力急劇上升,尤其是在東南亞地區。中國的崛起確實迅速,但它如何成功地將其崛起的實力轉化為實際政治影響力仍然是一個問題。本研究透過研究中國和緬甸關係的一個關鍵個案研究設計來回答這個問題。由於緬甸高度依賴中國,因此它是最有可能受到中國重大影響的國家之一。然而,如果在這種不平衡的關係下,緬甸的合作性較低,那麼中國的實際影響力可能被誇大。本研究採用經濟影響力綜合指數(CIEI)來顯示緬甸在經濟相互依賴方面最依賴哪個國家。CIEI顯示緬甸在短期內最依賴中國,並且不容易被替代。然而,考慮到這種高度相互依賴的關係,證據顯示,自2011年緬甸開始進行政治改革以來,其行為已經開始偏離中國在人權和無核世界等問題上的立場。此外,中國的影響力並未受到當地社區的歡迎,他們認為由中國支持的項目是剝削性的經濟冒險主義。這項研究通過分析中國在Myitsone水壩和Letpadaung銅礦項目中的投資,探討了這種反對的原因。結果表明,中國的軟實力並不像感知的那麼強大和受歡迎。相互依賴關係所產生的實力需要政治和社會凝聚力才能牢固建立。